English Club : English Reading : Short Stories : The Winepress : Comments
Here you can leave your comments and opinions about the short story, The Winepress.
it was really interesting and meaningful story
I like very much, This story is different of others so thanks to writer …………. Its touch to my heart…………
Good story nice one!
The plots are designed accurately. Entire story is revealed methodically with meticulous details. The art of generating curiosity in the minds of the guests and the readers is superb.
1. Where is the Quai Voltaire?
2. What do Charles de Gruse of his guests?
3. What are bateaux-Mouches?
4. A. Who tells the story to the guests?
B. Who was that person’s story?
5. How is Pierre on the vineyard?
6. Why Faniry was so jealous?
7. How Faniry deceased?
8. What Pierre told the staff about Faniry?
9. How is it that the only Pierre delicious wine made in 1965?
10. A. Guests have drunk the ‘wrong’ wine?
B. If so, when? If not, why not?
A good story,I like it
Oh God its so difficult to understand for the beginnier like me .there is alot of difficult vocabulary
but inspite of this story winepress is gud
Although effectively the vocabulary was an obstacle, I really liked the way that stands as its main theme the delight of consuming a good wine cause behind this story of love and dislikes you can do many conclusions, like for example everything that somepeople can risking for their selfishness in the search of their self welfare
Is hard read a long text in english like this, but is perfect for practice the reading.
Well, Frankly speaking the only good thing that i extracted out of this story is the extensive use of vocabulary…..so thanks author….. the moral was not highlighted clearly though, every reader will draw different conclusion out of it and accordingly may or may not be satisfied……but anyways it was worth reading…….lol
the story are interesting and a terrible. It’s help my-self have sight about jealousy very dangerous, change the women. The winepress not fail, the grape wine have before story not effect when we taste it.
its a good story.
Difficult for a student like me to understand.
Very interesting and well written. Congrats…For me the story is very deep and give a sort of moral lesson. It concern about how Europe and imperialism at all have been killing people by just “eating” or “drinking” them across the centuries (in a methaphorical way)…And, ironically when they “victims” are about to emigrate to Europe, they suffer the consequences of rascism and xenophobia…(Note that all the dinners are high class people, linked with the aristocracy and the army). The metaphore of the wine as the answering to the inmigration issue is magistral. It remembered me the movie “The cook, the thief, his woman and her lover” of Peter Greenaway. Thank you and forgive my poor english, please!!!
Now I’m gonna have nightmares tonight.
“In wine [there is the] truth”. I like red dessert wine. Thank you for the story. Everyone has her/his own “winepress” story.
i liked how the story was written and the different type of speech it used.
I love the story a lot. It was easy to aswered the questions after I read it. The vocabulary was a bonus as well.
superb story. liked a lot:)
I liked your method of teaching through of this storyand I also liked the storywhich shows us we must care of our thought and manage it and work on it.
nice story , but i don’t like the idea that he killed his wife. She does not deserve this end
A very good story, with a great ending – so that each reader could draw their own conclusion. Should be advanced not intermediate. I think Mr. Poe would be very proud of this writer.
I love wine , although the story had many strange words for my poor vocabulary, I could understand that the flavors of wines carries always came laden stories that not always as good as the taste of the wine.
It’s very good story, helped me learn a lots of new words. Thanks.
I enjoyed reading the short story but I want to know the moral lesson about the short story.
actually I find it kinda gross and scary
this story is scarey
i feel a pity for the wife but i think it was the reaction of what she did
Edgar Allen Poe re-incarnated. Great!!!
very beautiful story i am very happy in reading
Very interesting story. I also think that there were some difficult words, but thanks to God there are dictionaries
Can we get more stories, please?
Very good story!
this is really gerat story.thanks a lot
ITS TOO LONG AND SUCH A DIFFICULT FOR THE STUDENT TO UNDERSTAND THE WHOLE SCENE CREATED IN WINE PRESS
it’s really an interesting and amusing story.I’ll cover it in class tomorrow. I agree with the vocab issue.I think it’s a bit difficult for the students who don’t have the sufficient language skills.The exercises are very useful,though. thanks.
Well, it’s a good story, very interesting. But for people who are in Level Upper Intermediate the vocabulary is so difficult . Sorry for us, maybe our English classes aren’t good.
I think this is one of the most vital information for me. And i’m satisfied studying your article. But should remark on some general things, The website taste is ideal, the articles is in point of fact great : D. Just right job, cheers
woh…………..!!! its so interesting……….i lyk 2 read it again & again along with my frnds………..
It is a good story. By reading it, we know to avoid drinking wine.
Is it a true story?
its….weird… but cool…
teacher showed me this one!
this is my first time to join the discuss on internet.i am also an english learner,a learn by my self.i am very glad to find all the learners here to know i am not helpless.this story feels a little frightening.if i was there, i think, i may have spit out the meal i just ate.
as i muse on this story, i thought that if you are to migrate to france, be sure not to show sordid attitude towards the french it you don’t want to be the most palatable wine served at dinner time.
Oh, it’s so hard to learn English, but I like this language and I’m learning despite the difficulties. Soon I’ll become a great English speaker.
not nice but entartaining
nice web you have , for reading any suggestions 4 u. it is good to give the text reading with audio by the text read by a native speaker, we live in non english speaking country you text reading will really be helpful,especially for my student at the classroom. thank
very nice , thanks
I have not read such a intersting story before….
So nice story and there is some Quiz I like it so much …hope i can see u again bye2x ….
This is very good and also its helps me with some vocabulary words that i didnt know and thanks to the one who fix it bye now i hope you all the bests
It is very nice story and interesting
Reading it reminded me of Edgar Allan Poe. I very much think that De Gruse made the story up to see the reaction of his guests; immigration? living bad away from the native place, not strong enough to overlook the comments coming from the others, feeling inferior. The husband was in his country, why didn’t he try going back to Madagascar if he loved his wife so much? He was rich enough to leave everything to someone trustworthy.A glass of red wine a day is of vital importance.
Actually it is avery interesting story but a confusing one at the same time.what confuse me is the underlying meaning of it.May be it is the destroying effect of wine on happy marriage.How happy were this couple before wine appear in their life. At the end of the story there is amention that ” Fainry” is drunk.So that is what wine did to her happy marriage ,it turns her from “an angel to termagant”,actually
aperson blinded with suspect and jealousy.Finally wine kills her as she stumbled towards the winepress.
A wonderful story!The story is about wine.”She screamed, struggling to free herself”I am thinking what did she think about at that time? About immigation, love, family, indifference of her husband, or the tragic of her jealous?
How horrible, cruel, How could he do that to his wife?
Anyway thanks for sharing this story, it was interesting to read, and I’ll come more often.
the story is very good for our,but it’s very difficult in read its.
i did not like it.
iam trying to improve my english but this story iz very difficult to read !!!!
The story is intresting, I like it. I agree with the others that the writer was attaking the wine and wanted to give us a lesson about jeluosy. finally, the story is easy to understand.
I think it is a good story that I ever heard before. It shows terrible things about drinking and gives you a lesson of life. Wine is so bad,smoking is very bad.
it an exellent reading. it help me to techa my students.
In my opinion,the story is great where both the elements of suprise and intereste have been made highly.While the main theme is immigration issue , the sub theme was the wine.I agree that the auther was attaking the wine , though he speaks about it as something wonderful in France.I wanna say he wants manily to show that immigration made the lady jelouse and change her temper.
Love, jelous, drinking wine, kill are the result of immigration
The bottom line is the red color of the wine where all enjoyed was compared to the blood. Who knows maybe blood is making aroma to the wine since its the causive reason for it !!!
interesting! though i don’t understand everything in this story… i need to learn english vocabraly more XD
very nice story this …………i like this this story i sent my friends ……………………………….thank you
This is a deep story, Very interesting. I will looking for a sip of 65 red french wine
I’m trying to improve my English. This story helped me learn some new words and structures. And it was interesting. Thanks a lot.
Annualy I do the vintage… I think I’ll remainds me this story for long time…
Emad, i don’t think you know alcohol very well. As alcohol doesn’t make you some homicidal maniac. But yes it lowers your will and understanding, still the text doesn’t say anything about the guy being drunk in the story. Well overall very good story.
Thank you for the story.
It’s a well-written story and useful for people who want to improve their writing.
You’d better to read the story two times or more.
I think it is a good one coz it has many english words which are not familiar to me, but at the end its ambigous
I don’t understand thí sentences “But you do have to be French to recognize one”
Thank you for your assistance
hi my dears readers this story was very interesting the wine can’t make us happy many people when the faced with the problem instead of that to find the slotion way for that problem they are drinking the wine
and they are don’t care about their careers .
when some drinking on that time he don’t know on thing what every he want he can did easily that and their behavior will be separate form others
This is a short, biography with comprehension and vocabulary quizzes very helpful to incoming 9th grade readers. Fry’s Readability leveled at 5 sentences, perr 100 words and 145 syllables (proper names counted as one syllable only) = 9th Grade. I disagree that this is an ESL intermediate reading, though. I would consider it advanced reading-wise, however the quizzes are at 8th grade levels.
what a magnificent story,but bloody one……
this story is nice but little bit boaring.
they were very very nice stories. thanks for your all favors.
at first very difficult to understand
at last, very interesting
thanks ，a good stories i’ve never reading!!!
I also didn’t understand the last sentense. Somebody please clear it up!
Interesting story. It does explain a lot for me. Sometimes about life, about marriage, specially importance of selecting a better one(but not here in this story by Pierre) & the facts have to be faced if not,etc. And also feelings like jealous, angry,etc would not ever give us happiness eventually. It only makes people weak in both physically & intellectually. By the way a religion should advise us not only to avoid alcoholic drinks but also to protect the right to lives of others(to the fullest meaning of the letter, of all the living things on this whole planet).
It is a good read for English learners like us & I enjoyed it as a story, but never wanna see or hear something like that happens in this beautiful world.
Emad from Iran, Saveh Azad university Branch
I think it is a good story that I ever heard before. It shows terrible things about drinking and gives you a lesson of life. Wine is so bad, if somebody is drunk, cannot make decision, and cannot control him/her self. Although it gives you a temporary enjoyment but it regrets you for long time. If you are drunk, you may kill someone or violate one or may do else horrible deed. “This story shows you a sample, Pierre was a winegrower who likes her wife. After a while, they moved in France due to the death of his parents in a car crash and to mange their vineyard. After that, his wife, Faniry, became so jealous and they had some argument. Therefore, that one day when they were so drunk Faniry entered the winery; she wanted to have a baby after that accusations and insults but Pierre did not see eye to eye with her. Thus, they fight and suddenly the screw of the press caught at her hair and dragged her in. her husband didn’t do any effort to save her how terrible. When he made sure she died, switched the current off. Faniry’s blood had mixed to the wine and smells so good”; ‘Charles Jousselin de Gruse wanted to show disadvantages of drinking by telling this story to their guests’. That is why my religion forbade alcoholic drinks.
In my opinion this story is so cruel. It is alike “The october game” by Ray Bradbury. I don’t like it,too.
it likes Alan pos stories
i Though The Story Was A Load Of SHIT! To Be HOnest!
I wanna take a sip of 65 red wine if possible.
I really enjoyed the story but I didn’t understand in the end the answer of de Gruse,were they drinking the wine with Faniry’s blood,yes or no?????
i love this story from begining to end..its also a lesson.
I really enjoyed the story.it have alot of voc.,but i was expecting it’s end it was not surprising for me.
GOOD LUCK FOR THE WRITTER
IT was good story and it have alot of meaning realy i liked it
I love this story, one of my favourite story I’ ve read. I love the manner the author described scenery in Paris, Madagascar and more
absolutely ,very good story … I was very surprised when I read ..you should read story
Very interesting story ! I never drink wine and now i know the reason why, Lol. Thank you Marcia
it was very good story.
Thanks u so much teacher….i Done already…The Wine story very interesting…:-)
I will think about it when I drink wine!How terrible I fell!!
The winepress story is funny and useful at the same time.
Funny because it makes you laugh at thier drinking of Vinery
useful because it gives lessons regarding jelousy.
It’s very funny to learn english with this “lovely” story and I hope that I will think to it when I will drink a wine.
(Thank you Marcia!).
My group in IES Calvia loved this history.
It was very nice, red and bloody. Thank you very much.
Esther from Mallorca (actually i am from Valencia)
My Adult ESL group really enjoyed this story – the subtlety and ambiguity of it as well as the mix of familiar and challenging vocabulary. Thank you to whoever put this exercise together.
Really it is very good story, a lot of smart and intelligent between lines meaning, he answered his guests indirectly about immigration issue…
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Terms | Privacy | Contact | Report error
© 1997-2014 EnglishClub