EnglishClub
Home Learn English Teach English MyEnglishClub Home Learn English Teach English MyEnglishClub

Please note that these ESL Forums are NOT part of MyEnglishClub. To post at these ESL Forums please register ↑ first.

Can hostage-taking ever be considered justifiable?

Monthly topics for discussion

Moderator: TalkingPoint

Postby MissLT » Sun Jul 03, 2005 6:51 pm

danyet wrote:You are still adding your own interpretation to the original Question. The question askes if hostage taking can
ever be justified. You are now pondering what the sister did to deserve kidnapping. This is a moot point. You are also stating things like we should not take the law into our own hands. This is also a moot point since I have already set the scenerio in a lawless land.

When it is totally up to you to save your sisters life you will do whatever it takes to get her back or you will allow her to die. It is that simple. So far from your posts I think that I am glad not to be your sister.

Don't you think you're doing the same thing with your "scenario" And if your scenario had happened, my "moot" point would have happened. Just look at things that way, okay.
User avatar
MissLT
Ethereal Member
 
Posts: 5911
Joined: Wed Apr 06, 2005 3:05 pm
Status: Other

Postby Danyet » Sun Jul 03, 2005 11:23 pm

Ok, you have convinced me. You are right. The bad guys have there own reasons to kidnap, rape and kill my sister and I see now that I should respect that and not try to beat the information out of them. I will just let them kill her. Yes, that's it because afterall, I would not want to be guilty of harming in any way, a vermin ridden phsychopathic killer bent on the destruction and torture of everyone he meets. As a matter of fact I think I'll just kill myself now to save him the bother!
User avatar
Danyet
Keeper of the Board
Keeper of the Board
 
Posts: 1756
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 2:29 am
Location: USA
Status: English Teacher

Postby MissLT » Sun Jul 03, 2005 11:44 pm

danyet wrote:Ok, you have convinced me. You are right. The bad guys have there own reasons to kidnap, rape and kill my sister and I see now that I should respect that and not try to beat the information out of them. I will just let them kill her. Yes, that's it because afterall, I would not want to be guilty of harming in any way, a vermin ridden phsychopathic killer bent on the destruction and torture of everyone he meets. As a matter of fact I think I'll just kill myself now to save him the bother!

So you think it's right if anyone has the same excuse as yours, "yeah I should kill that bastard because he's kidnapped my sister" blah blah blah and blah. Let me tell you when someone wants an excuse to cover his bad deed, there are million of excuses to cover it. Look at Bush and you'll see how his a$$ has been lying to the American people. Yeah sure, it was okay to keep those people as hostages and it was okay to torture them. Don't be a smart a$$ and make all the 'scenarios' before thinking of the action and result. If you think being in denial to convince yourself that holding a hostage is okay then go ahead and do so. I've proven to you that those two brothers were wrong and their action taking your sister as a hostage was not justifiable and I've proven to you that if you hold someone as a hostage, you would likely torture them for your own pleasure. What have you been proven huh Mr. Smart-A$$? Some 'scenario' will work and holding someone else as a hostage would be okay? Or instead of trying to 'rescue' your sister, it'd be better to torture the kidnapper for what his team-mate was doing to your sister. Wow, the scenario is great and it works. Yaaaay, high five to you. :roll: :roll: :roll:
User avatar
MissLT
Ethereal Member
 
Posts: 5911
Joined: Wed Apr 06, 2005 3:05 pm
Status: Other

Postby Shazzam » Wed Jul 06, 2005 6:52 am

danyet wrote:I hope you are joking, I don't know what kind of English you speak but anywhere I have lived two brothers means simply that. So in the scenerio your sister has been stolen. And you have captured one of two brothers. Most people would go to great lengths to rescue a family member but the original question mentions nothing about torture. The reason I used two family members as hostage takers in the scenerio was to try to avoid the torture question if possible, because an even exchange of hostages is more likely with the presence of blood ties, without the need for brutality. So, somehow, from your answer I get the feeling that we agree. There is justifiable hostage taking. It must be scary for you. This revelation I mean.

So, how about torture? Would you refuse to beat your hostage even though you know that if you did you would be saving the life of your sister? I mean time is running out, since she is buried in a box with very little air left. Oh, what to do. ....Let sister die or beat the information out of bad guy..Hmmm!


Still doesn't mean you will get the result you are looking for does it? Using your case scenerio "you beat the hostage for information". What happens if you don't get the information; and your sister still dies? What have you achieved?

Certainly not forgiveness!
User avatar
Shazzam
Rough Diamond Member
 
Posts: 1826
Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2005 4:40 am
Location: Australia

Postby Danyet » Wed Jul 06, 2005 6:00 pm

shazzam1452 wrote:
Still doesn't mean you will get the result you are looking for does it? Using your case scenerio "you beat the hostage for information". What happens if you don't get the information; and your sister still dies? What have you achieved?

Certainly not forgiveness!


I am not looking for forgiveness. I have not done anything that needs to be forgiven and I am certain that my prisoner is not looking for forgiveness, otherwise he would tell me where his brother is hiding my sister.

So what does has "forgiveness" have to do with this?

You ask what I have achieved? I have custody of one of the perpetrators who will be punnished for his crimes.
What did you think? He would be let go?
User avatar
Danyet
Keeper of the Board
Keeper of the Board
 
Posts: 1756
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 2:29 am
Location: USA
Status: English Teacher

Postby shokin » Wed Jul 06, 2005 6:39 pm

Could you repeat me any other way the meaning of the "hostage-taking" ?

That is one first discussion that I don't understand.

And I am not at home (so I have not any dictionnary).

Edit : oh ! you don't need to explain me ! I understood !

No ! this is not the good question !

taking hostage is only one "after" of what one did. The answer is in what he did and why he did so.

Inself, taking hostage is a double-weakness : by taking hostage (or one gun) you show that you "cannot" solve the problem without it (actually you don't know what to do) and you take a charge on you, which make you less mobile (less possible move). Moreover you don't want to kill the hostage (or to use your gun). So you don't feel more in security. (but more dependant, by believing that hostage can help you)

Shokin
Nous sommes libres. Wir sind frei. We are free. Somos libres. Siamo liberi.
User avatar
shokin
Polished Diamond Member
 
Posts: 2135
Joined: Mon Jan 24, 2005 11:32 pm
Location: Switzerland
Status: English Learner

Postby Shazzam » Wed Jul 06, 2005 11:13 pm

What I meant was "forgiving yourself". I mean beating someone to no end (no result) etc...how could you live with yourself. You are just as bad as the perpetrator. I still don't think your argument justifies taking another person hostage. I agree with SHOKIN it is a sign of weakness!
Last edited by Shazzam on Fri Jul 08, 2005 8:08 am, edited 3 times in total.
User avatar
Shazzam
Rough Diamond Member
 
Posts: 1826
Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2005 4:40 am
Location: Australia

Postby Danyet » Thu Jul 07, 2005 6:52 am

So far, all you "gentle people" have shown me is that you think that your sweet and innocent little sister's life is equal to that of a sadistic murderer's.
User avatar
Danyet
Keeper of the Board
Keeper of the Board
 
Posts: 1756
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 2:29 am
Location: USA
Status: English Teacher

Postby Shazzam » Thu Jul 07, 2005 12:08 pm

danyet wrote:So far, all you "gentle people" have shown me is that you think that your sweet and innocent little sister's life is equal to that of a sadistic murderer's.


We will have to agree to disagree on this topic. I really don't have anything further to add. In my mind hostage taking is a form of terrorism; and nothing you or anyone else can say to me can justify that course of action.

I wish you all the best in life.

Signing off!
User avatar
Shazzam
Rough Diamond Member
 
Posts: 1826
Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2005 4:40 am
Location: Australia

Previous

Return to Talking Point Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests