The answer versus the explanation

English grammar questions, answered by Alan

Moderator: Alan

Post Reply
keleigh
Member
Posts: 2
Joined: Sat Oct 09, 2004 1:47 am

The answer versus the explanation

Post by keleigh »

On an application I recently completed, it asked you to identify the mistake in the following question by underling it, re-writing the question and explaining your answer. It's been a week since I applied and I'm still loosing sleep over one of the questions, if anyone can help me I would be beyond grateful!!!

1. "Why didn't you answer the telephone?"
"Because I had a bath."

2. "Because I was in the bath."

3. This is where I get lost, I'm almost certain that the change I made was correct, the problem is I have no idea why...

Thanks for any help you might be able to offer, and/or advise on where I might be able to find help. :mrgreen:

- Keleigh- :mrgreen: :oops:
User avatar
Alan
Teacher/Moderator
Teacher/Moderator
Posts: 15204
Joined: Mon Dec 29, 2003 7:56 pm
Status: Teacher of English
Location: Japan

Post by Alan »

If #2 was your amended version, it was certainly correct.
'Because I had a bath' is grammatically sound, but does not constitute a reasonable response to the original question, since, being couched in the past simple tense of an action verb, it fails to indicate the temporal overlap between the two events (the phone ringing and being in the bath). 'I was...', on the other hand, being the past tense of a stative verb, is able naturally to indicate that connection, and therefore does constitute a reasonable response. (I hope that's not too technical!)
keleigh
Member
Posts: 2
Joined: Sat Oct 09, 2004 1:47 am

Post by keleigh »

Thank you SO much, I can't begin to tell you how many hours I spent studying the various sections of my old S.A.T prep books, trying to understand the reason for an answer I just knew... Thank-you,thank-you,thank-you!!!
-Keleigh- :lol:
User avatar
Alan
Teacher/Moderator
Teacher/Moderator
Posts: 15204
Joined: Mon Dec 29, 2003 7:56 pm
Status: Teacher of English
Location: Japan

Post by Alan »

You're welcome, you're welcome, you're welcome!

:D
Post Reply