I have trouble with the following question:
Father says that either you or I (is, am, are) to blame for the broken window.
I think 'is' is the correct answer but my teacher says 'am' is the correct answer.
Please help.
is, am, are?
Moderator: EC
-
- Member
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Wed May 25, 2011 2:12 am
- Status: Learner of English
-
- Member
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2011 6:54 pm
- Status: Learner of English
Re: is, am, are?
I think your teacher is right: (is , am, are) should coincide with the last subject( in your sentence it's "I') . So - I am to blame....
-
- Member
- Posts: 44
- Joined: Wed Sep 14, 2011 11:38 pm
- Status: Other
Re: is, am, are?
"Am" is correct, but "are" is also acceptable. Definitely not "is."
Note that there are ways to avoid the problem altogether:
"Father says that either you are to blame for the broken window or I am."
"Father says that one of us is to blame for the broken window."
"Father says that the blame for the broken window rests on either you or me."
Note that there are ways to avoid the problem altogether:
"Father says that either you are to blame for the broken window or I am."
"Father says that one of us is to blame for the broken window."
"Father says that the blame for the broken window rests on either you or me."
- JCloninger
- Member
- Posts: 14
- Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2012 10:36 pm
- Status: Teacher of English
Re: is, am, are?
"Is" would not be correct. "Is" is used for third-person singular pronouns (he, she, it).Chrisooi wrote:I have trouble with the following question:
Father says that either you or I (is, am, are) to blame for the broken window.
I think 'is' is the correct answer but my teacher says 'am' is the correct answer.
Please help.
Use "am" since it follows "I" ("I am to blame").
If you rewrite it "Father says that you", then you "are".
- Josef Essberger
- Admin/Teacher
- Posts: 1798
- Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2003 6:56 am
- Status: Teacher of English
- Location: England
Re: is, am, are?
Father says that you or I am to blame.
Father says that I or you are to blame.
As JCloninger implies, the general rule is to conjugate the verb for the subject closest to the verb.
Father says that I or you are to blame.
As JCloninger implies, the general rule is to conjugate the verb for the subject closest to the verb.
-
- Member
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2012 7:59 pm
- Status: Teacher of English
Re: is, am, are?
Father says that you or I are to blame.
This sounds find to me.
Father says that you or I is to blame.
This sounds ok, but not as good as the first one.
*Father says that you or I am to blame.
This sounds very weird to me.
I don't think the principle of proximity applies here. Would anyone say "The horses and the dog is very well behaved today"?
The principle of proximity applies to situations where there is some distance between the noun phrase head of the subject and the verb usually because there is a length postmodifier, as in "The filing of the false, fraudulent charges are a complete contraction" (Joseph McCarthy) where the subject NP is singular but the modifier that is closest to the verb is plural.
But that's not what's happening in "Father says that you or I am to blame." Here we have a compound subject: two pronouns conjoined by "and". My intuition is that the plural verb is better here. According to Merriam-Webster's Dictionary of English Usage, the plural verb is usually used with compound subjects (singular nouns compounded by "and").
This sounds find to me.
Father says that you or I is to blame.
This sounds ok, but not as good as the first one.
*Father says that you or I am to blame.
This sounds very weird to me.
I don't think the principle of proximity applies here. Would anyone say "The horses and the dog is very well behaved today"?
The principle of proximity applies to situations where there is some distance between the noun phrase head of the subject and the verb usually because there is a length postmodifier, as in "The filing of the false, fraudulent charges are a complete contraction" (Joseph McCarthy) where the subject NP is singular but the modifier that is closest to the verb is plural.
But that's not what's happening in "Father says that you or I am to blame." Here we have a compound subject: two pronouns conjoined by "and". My intuition is that the plural verb is better here. According to Merriam-Webster's Dictionary of English Usage, the plural verb is usually used with compound subjects (singular nouns compounded by "and").
- Josef Essberger
- Admin/Teacher
- Posts: 1798
- Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2003 6:56 am
- Status: Teacher of English
- Location: England
Re: is, am, are?
There is no "and" in the original sentence.anderson wrote:Here we have a compound subject: two pronouns conjoined by "and"
-
- Member
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2012 7:59 pm
- Status: Teacher of English
Re: is, am, are?
right, they're conjoined by "or" not "and". The principle is the same.
-
- Member
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2012 7:59 pm
- Status: Teacher of English
Re: is, am, are?
No, I'm wrong. For pronouns joined by "or", MWDEU saysanderson wrote:right, they're conjoined by "or" not "and". The principle is the same.
Compound singular nouns with or or nor are supposed to take a singular verb and in current use usually do. The plural verb is most likely to appear where the notion of plurality is suggested by negative construction or when the writer is thinking of "this or that or both".